Independent design study 2024–26
Only a little. I wrote a geometric-programming model of a 5‑tonne regional cargo plane that runs on hydrogen fuel cells, then asked how much of its cruise power solar cells could supply. At sensible wing shapes the answer is 2 to 3 percent. Past that, the cells need more area than the aeroplane has.
01 · The question
Sizing an aircraft is a loop inside a loop. A heavier battery wants a bigger wing, the bigger wing wants a stronger spar, and the spar adds weight again. Iterate by hand and you stop when you get tired, not when you reach the best design.
A geometric program writes every relationship as a posynomial. That turns the whole loop into a convex problem, so the solver returns the global optimum rather than a local one that happens to look fine. Where the physics refuses that form, I fitted posynomial surrogates to data instead, aerofoil polars from XFLR5 among them.
The objective is simple: minimise take-off mass for a 5-tonne payload flown 500 km at 40 m/s, then see how much solar the optimum will accept.
02 · Explore
Aspect ratio (span² ÷ wing area) turned out to be the lever that matters most. Every number below is a full solve from the paper's sweep at the design point.
03 · The solar limit
The optimiser may add cells until they need more area than the wing and fuselage tops provide. That cap arrives early. At 40 m/s and A = 11, solar tops out near 2.5 percent of cruise power. A long, thin wing (A ≈ 25) reaches about 6 percent, but by then the aircraft weighs 67 tonnes.
Flying on sunlight alone needs about ten times the area the airframe offers at best, and the gap widens with speed. The A = 25 and 33 designs never close at all.
04 · Sensitivities
The solver reports how much the optimum moves when each input moves. At A = 11, +1.15 for payload means 1% more payload costs 1.15% more take-off mass. Payload and structure dominate; range barely registers. This is a structure-limited aircraft, not an energy-limited one.
05 · Better cells?
Today's high-end cells convert about 25 percent of sunlight. Raise that and the solar share climbs in a straight line, but from a low base: at A = 11 it reaches 4.3 percent at 40 percent efficiency and 10.7 percent at an impossible 100.
06 · Limits
The model covers aerodynamics, a wing box sized for bending, tail booms, fuel-cell and hydrogen-tank mass, solar generation, the mission energy balance, take-off and an emergency diversion. Its answer is a hydrogen fuel-cell freighter in which sunlight trims a few percent off cruise energy, and nothing more.
It is built to be reused. Change the payload class, the mission or the technology numbers and the same program re-solves in seconds, which is what the live solver lets you do.
Where it stops being trustworthy
Your turn
The live solver runs the same model on a server. Move payload, range, speed, cell efficiency or the sun's position and it re-optimises the aircraft in a few seconds.